The ocean is taking up more of our carbon, but the land isn’t keeping up
A new study suggests the world’s land carbon sink has stalled since 1990, while the ocean has become the dominant carbon sink.
For decades, forests, soils and the ocean have quietly soaked up around half of the carbon dioxide we release into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels. A new study published in Science on 12 November shows that land and ocean have behaved very differently as carbon sinks over the past 30 years.
Scientists at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at UC San Diego analysed more than three decades of air samples collected at remote sites around the world. They looked at oxygen as well as CO2, which helps to tell the two sinks apart.
The difference is that when plants on land absorb CO2, they release oxygen. When the ocean absorbs CO2 through chemical reactions in sweater, oxygen isn’t affected. Tracking both gases over time shows how much carbon was going where.
Between 1990 and 2019, the ocean absorbed about 35% of fossil fuel emissions, and the amount it takes up each year has kept growing. Land ecosystems absorbed about 13%, but their contribution has not grown. It peaked in the decade centred on 2009 and has generally declined since.
That result is at odds with many climate models which assume that the land sink has strengthened over time, yet current estimates show them falling. “It was very surprising to see how the net land sink has not kept pace with rising CO2 levels,” said lead author Eric Morgan, adding that it may be fragile.
The ocean’s increasing role as a carbon sink comes at a cost; this carbon lowers pH, a process known as ocean acidification. The researchers also warn the sink could weaken in future, because warmer water is less capable of storing CO2. It also mixes less efficiently into the deep ocean, which typically locks away carbon for long periods of time.
The findings matter because climate models are used to work out how quickly emissions need to fall to meet temperature targets. If they overestimate how much carbon the land will absorb, our understanding of decarbonisation is incorrect and the margin for error on those pathways is smaller than assumed.
The study was supported by the US National Science Foundation, NOAA and Schmidt Sciences, and builds on a record begun by the Scripps O2 Program in 1989.